watch
Jul 07, 2026

Prince Wrote “Nothing Compares 2 U” in Hours. Sinéad O’Connor Made the World Watch It Cry.

The answer is Prince.

He wrote and first recorded “Nothing Compares 2 U” in 1984 at his Flying Cloud Drive warehouse in Eden Prairie, before Paisley Park was finished. Engineer Susan Rogers was there. He went into a room with a notebook, came back, and sang it. Rogers said it came out like a sneeze. He decided it did not fit the Prince he was selling that year. He pulled his vocal, added orchestration, and handed the song to The Family — the short-lived group built around Susannah Melvoin and Paul “St. Paul” Peterson. Their 1985 album version barely traveled.

In 1990 Sinéad O’Connor cut a stripped arrangement with Nellee Hooper for I Do Not Want What I Haven’t Got. The single and the one-take-feeling video — her face, the tear — went worldwide. She has said the “flowers that you planted, Mama” line made her think of her own mother. The performance is hers. The copyright is Prince’s.

Who the lyric was for is still an argument inside the camp: Melvoin and a cooling relationship; Sandy Scipioni, the housekeeper who left when her father died and took the household’s center of gravity with her; maybe both. Prince did not need the song to be a public confession. That is one reason he could give it away.

Other posts