Judy Collins and Stephen Stills’s Old Romance
Judy Collins and Stephen Stills’s Old Romance
The pair on touring together and on their new album, “Everybody Knows.” It’s a collaboration fifty years in the making.

By John SeabrookSeptember 18, 2017

On a recent evening, the singer Judy Collins, who has lived in a classic six on West End Avenue for many years, had a visit from an old flame, Stephen Stills.
“Don’t you look sharp!” Collins exclaimed as Stills, who was wearing a dark suit jacket over a black T-shirt, came in and kissed her on both cheeks. They sat at the dining-room table. Stills was grumpy at first about his squealing hearing aids (he is all but deaf in one ear), flinging them down on the table in frustration. Collins asked soothingly if he would like a Coca-Cola.
Stills, seventy-two, and Collins, seventy-eight, are touring together, and they have an album, “Everybody Knows”—new songs, some catalogue, a few covers—coming out this week. Their collaboration, fifty years in the making, is “the world’s oldest blooming flower,” Stills said, gamely trying to remember first meeting Collins, at an Eric Clapton show at the Whisky in Los Angeles, in the late nineteen-sixties.
“I kissed her hand. And she said, ‘Oh, these kids!’ But I was in the perfect mental state to be overwhelmed by an older woman.” He added, “And those eyes are even better live.”
“Oh!” Collins said, smiling.
Stills, then recently of Buffalo Springfield but not yet of C.S.N., offered to play guitar on the album that Collins was making, “Who Knows Where the Time Goes.”
“I don’t really remember that night,” Collins said. “I was probably very drunk. I had that tendency in those days.”
Stills noted that alcohol was not his particular poison back then. “I never drank until later, because my father was such an object lesson in how not to act. And, lo and behold, in the nineteen-eighties I turned into him!” His mother was also an alcoholic. “I never met anyone who had gone to the dry cleaners successfully.”
Stills and Collins were soon a couple. “It happened very fast,” Collins said.
“Well, I was a whirling dervish of a person,” Stills replied. “And I had all this stuff starting to pop.”
“It was very intense,” Collins continued, “and full of the music. You have to imagine: you’re sitting in the studio with someone who is so brilliant, and you are both so ambitious.”
“I was off to be a rock star,” Stills said. “She was off to be a glamour-puss.”
Their bicoastal relationship did not survive the winter, but it ended with one of rock’s greatest breakup songs, “Suite: Judy Blue Eyes,” which Stills composed in the spring of 1968. “The three parts were incomplete songs, and they just sort of melted together—like cheese,” Stills said, simulating rivulets of molten fromage with his fingers. “And in one of those enlightened moments I went, ‘A suite!’ ” (The concluding “doo-doo-doo-doo-doo” part came later, in the studio.)
That spring, Collins recalled, “I was out in L.A. to play the Santa Monica Civic, and you came to the hotel and you brought me this beautiful guitar”—a Martin 00-42 from the nineteen-twenties, on which Stills wrote the song.
“And you sang me the song. And we both wept. And I said, ‘It’s beautiful, but it’s not going to get me back.’ ”
As he was leaving, Stills gave the guitar to Collins, to keep.
The years passed. “We tried very hard to destroy ourselves,” Stills said. “I was much too close to the Rolling Stones.” Collins got sober in 1978; Stills did, too, eventually. They kept checking in.
“How could you not, if someone wrote that song for you?” Collins asked.
A few years ago, they found themselves sharing the bill at an A.A.R.P. convention in Orlando. “We laughed so hard about that,” Stills said. “But then there was this thought: Maybe it’s time we finished things off”—by making music together.
What happened to the Judy Blue Eyes guitar?
“I have it here!” Collins said, jumping up to fetch it from another room. She returned with the instrument.
“Didn’t it go to Colorado to dry out, or something?” Stills asked.
“No, it’s always been here.”
Collins swiftly tuned the guitar and handed it to Stills. Holding it awkwardly, the way a novice might, he touched the strings once, then put the guitar down abruptly, propping the peghead against the dining-room table.
“I can’t hear it,” he said softly. ♦
Penned in 1974, This Gentle Anthem Traded Heartbreak for the Most Stoic Farewell Ever Sung.

Released in 1974, this ballad wasn't a tearful breakdown, but rather the quietest, most resilient goodbye ever recorded.

Released in 1974, Dolly Parton’s “I Will Always Love You” arrived at a defining moment when the singer was ready to forge her own musical destiny.
It wasn’t simply another country single; it felt like a turning point where profound gratitude, inner conflict, and a fierce desire for independence all collided into something sharper and incredibly tender.
From the very first acoustic guitar strum—stark, slow, and unadorned—the song sets a tone that feels both mournful and resolute, as if the singer is holding back a heavy sigh.
That quiet tension became the heartbeat of the track, pulling listeners into a space where love isn't about possession, but rather the graceful act of letting go.
At its core, “I Will Always Love You” is about the quiet courage it takes to walk away.
Unlike typical tear-soaked country ballads of the era, the track is a promise, an acknowledgment that even though paths must diverge, the deep appreciation for the other person will never fade.

Written by Parton as a professional and personal farewell to her longtime mentor and duet partner, Porter Wagoner, the track carries a fragility that reflects the heavy toll of choosing between loyalty and her own artistic evolution.
That evolution is unmistakable here, with stripped-down production that steps back to let raw emotional honesty take center stage.
Parton’s vocal performance plays a crucial role. Her voice doesn’t explode with rage or theatrical agony; instead, it trembles gently while maintaining a remarkable composure, letting the heartbreak bleed through line by line.
“If I should stay
I would only be in your way
So I'll go, but I know
I'll think of you each step of the way”
As the chorus arrives, it doesn’t offer a dramatic climax so much as it deepens the sense of acceptance. The phrase “I will always love you” becomes less of a romantic cliché and more of a heavy, heartfelt blessing.
Musically, the restraint of the instrumentation creates an expansive, lonely atmosphere, leaving Parton’s delicate soprano suspended in the memories of what was.
That masterful storytelling cemented Parton not just as a stellar vocalist, but as one of the greatest songwriters of her generation. When the single reached No. 1 on the Billboard Hot Country Songs chart, it confirmed that absolute vulnerability resonated deeply with a wide audience.
Yet beyond its chart success, the song carried a mood that felt deeply personal.

It spoke to listeners who understood the agonizing difficulty of leaving something beautiful behind in order to move forward.
Decades later, even as the world rightfully marvels at Whitney Houston’s powerhouse R&B rendition, Parton’s acoustic original retains its pure, devastating core. It reminds us of those quiet, sleepless nights when we realize that the ultimate act of love is sometimes simply setting someone free.
As the final notes fade, the song doesn’t leave behind regret, but rather a quiet peace.
“I Will Always Love You” lingers not because it offers a tidy resolution, but because it captures a fleeting moment of profound maturity.
In the end, Dolly didn’t just write a hit—she built a monument to the most beautiful kind of heartbreak, and its quiet echo continues to resonate through time.